Sawyer was surprised to hear that Pepper had a crush list.
Sawyer was sad to hear that he wasn't on Pepper's crush list.
Sawyer got upset that Pepper didn't put him on her crush list.
Sawyer told himself out loud, "I guess we don't have as much in common as I thought we do." then got embarrassed when Troy asked him what he said about Pepper.
Sawyer tried to tell Pepper that he was upset about her crush list without telling her.
Pepper told Sawyer that she loved the idea of a boot list.
Sawyer said he didn't know why he cared, but he hated that he wasn't on her list.
Sawyer tried to change, so he'll be on the list.
After pepper told him that it wasn't a crush list but a fashion list about which bulldog was the most fashionably challenged and how she was making a calendar with all of them on it.
Pepper didn't think that there was anything wrong about Sawyer's look, and that it works for him.
They both agreed that they wanted to be on each other's crush list.
Pepper thought that Bella was exaggerating on how bad Sawyer's locker smells until she got to smell it herself.
Pepper organized Sawyer's locker.
They temporarily break-up in the episode, but get back together.
Some of the things Sawyer kept were actually mementos of his and Pepper's relationship (e.g., a sandwich from their first date (though Sawyer's original intention was to finish it)).
Both went to the playoffs (real and unofficial one).
Both were driven by their rivalry with the Red Devils of their respective teams (Sawyer football, Pepper cheerleading).
Both are now on good terms with the Red Devils of their respective teams (Sawyer because he thought that they were glad that they won without playing because Bella couldn't, only to be revealed that the Red Devils coach didn't want to lose to a girl. And Pepper because she (and Sophie) thought that the Red Devil cheerleaders were pranking with a cake that said Good Luck Cheerlosers (the cake company made a mistake, as the Bulldogs cheer coach said that she gave her cake that said Happy Barfday instead of Birthday)).